Pocket Hole Jig or Dovetail Joint?

Pocket hole jig or dovetail joint? Which is the stronger joint 13.10.17

Pocket hole jig or dovetail joint? Which is the stronger woodworking joint?

Get the answer here…

Here at Gifkins we often get asked what are the strongest woodworking joints to use. So, in this latest series we tackle the strength of a dovetail joint, compared to a pocket hole jig joint.

We see, from time to time, a lot of products entering the market that claim to be many things. So let’s look at some pros and cons for each joint:

Pocket Hole Jig

Image sourced from Wikipedia

Pocket hole jig joint pros and cons

Pros:
– Does not require complex measurements
– Can be quick
– Simple to use
Cons:
– Joints can break more easily the more conventional joints
– Once broken, the joint cannot be repaired
– Really is just a short term fix.

 

Dovetail jointDovetail joint pros and cons

Pros:
– Extremely strong timber joint, especially for drawers
– No nails or screws needed, just glue!
– Classic looking and very common
– The Gifkins Dovetail makes it so simple…
-No measuring! No fiddling! No fuss!
Cons:
– Making dovetails by hand can be hard for a beginner
– Without the simplicity of the Gifkins jig you can get misalignment.

So, in conclusion we can see in the image above, how the interlocking pins and tails make for an extremely strong jointing method. The dovetail joint is one of the most attractive woodworking joints; and combined with different timber species can give a very satisfying result. From Chinese emperors to ancient Egyptians dovetail joints have been known to exist.

For further information on history and types of dovetail joints, visit this link.

Pocket Hole Jig or Dovetail Joint?

See Col from Gifkins giving a great demonstration on how to use the dovetail jig here.

For a great range of the Gifkins dovetail jigs CLICK HERE.